On October 14, Google announced it no longer recommends the Ajax crawling scheme they published in 2009. Columnist Mark Munroe dives into the question of whether this means you can now count on Google to successfully crawl and index an Ajax site.
Web designers and engineers love Ajax for building Single Page Applications (SPA) with popular frameworks like Angular and React. Pure Ajax implementations can provide a smooth, interactive web application that performs more like a dedicated desktop application.
Back in 2009, Google came up with a solution to make Ajax crawlable. That method either creates “escaped fragment” URLs (ugly URLs) or more recently, clean URLs with a Meta=”fragment” tag on the page.
A popular food site switched to Angular, believing that Google could crawl it. They lost about 70 percent of their organic traffic and are still recovering from that debacle. Ultimately, both sites went to pre-rendering HTML snapshots, the recommended Ajax crawling solution at the time.
And then, on Oct 14, Google said this:
We are no longer recommending the AJAX crawling proposal we made back in 2009.
Note that they are still supporting their old proposal. (There have been some articles announcing that they are no longer supporting it, but that is not true — they are simply no longer recommending that approach.)
In deprecating the old recommendation, they seemed to be saying they can now crawl Ajax.
Then, just a week after the announcement, a client with a newly launched site asked me to check it out. This was an Angular site, again an SPA Ajax implementation.
Upon examining Google’s index and cache, we saw some partially indexed pages without all the content getting crawled. I reiterated my earlier recommendation of using HTML snapshots or progressive enhancement.
This site was built with Angular, which does not yet support server-side rendering (again, in this case, the server initially renders a page to serve up the HTML document), so progressive enhancement would be difficult to support, and HTML snapshots are still the best solution for them.
She replied, “But why? Everything I read tells me Google can crawl Ajax.”
Can they? Let’s take a deeper look at the new recommendation in regard to Ajax.
Source – MarketingLand.com